Supreme Court Cases on Same-Sex Marriage: Where the Church Goes from Here

Honorable Retired Federal Judge Rollin Van Broekhoven, Mark Bailey and Darrell Bock discuss in detail the Supreme Court decisions on the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) and Prop 8, as well as what the current cultural shift means for how the church should approach its mission.

2:28Legal summary of the two Supreme Court decisions on same-sex marriage3:43The arguments for dissent in the cases5:35What was decided in the DOMA case, the majority argument, and preliminary observations about how decisions are presented to the public8:07How decisions get written and what they look to accomplish8:58What is the difference between what we hear in the press and what the Court decided? Kennedy’s opinion, the Prop 8 argument, and the Prop 8 dissent12:26How does jurisdiction work in normal decisions?13:12A closer look at the DOMA case: what was the actual decision?16:20Background to DOMA and the facts of this specific case 21:04Federal vs. state law: if one state recognizes a same sex marriage, does that apply to all states?22:42Is the lack of a legal mandate in this case the same as a philosophical influence on culture?23:38Summary of the DOMA decision and its potential implications24:23The Scalia dissent26:47Does the law handle certain kinds of moral situations poorly, especially where a moral consensus is lacking? How the same sex argument is made in the Kennedy opinion30:23How the definition of marriage is handled in the decision31:07Explaining the cultural shift that created the space for this decision32:20The judge’s reflection on what is happening in the law in our shifting culture and when there is no public moral consensus34:22How Kennedy handles dissent to his view34:57What is the response of churches and believers in light of these realities in our culture? How do Christians engage people who may not accept theological argumentation?39:50The importance of winning both the heart and the mind to the gospel, to think and teach Christianly about marriage41:06How the homosexual community has successfully made their argument to the public and culture42:43Example of how this can be discussed and what the church has failed to do44:55One look at how our culture handled this discussion recently: Jason Collins versus Chris Broussard46:08What Catholics teach us about the mind, the concept of the Common Good, how we talk about marriage today, and what we should say about marriage47:54Discussing the value of Common Good49:28Opportunities to present a biblical case for marriage50:32Is something true because it is in the Bible or is it in the Bible because it is true? What is the point of this difference?51:54How a Christian living in a country where Christians are in the minority looks at this kind of engagement: lessons from John Dickson in Australia55:15A look at the first century: Mars Hill in Acts 1758:31Judge Van Broekhoven on Acts 171:01:15Those who respond in Acts 171:02:35How we discuss the need for God1:03:45Why marriage is important; the God-Christ picture as a mirror on marriage1:05:18An opportunity for pre-evangelism

About the Contributors

More Podcast

View All