Book Reviews

Nathaniel Taylor, New Haven Theology, and the Legacy of Jonathan Edwards

Douglas A. Sweeney New York 2002-12-05

Sweeney is the chair of the department of church history and the history of Christian thought at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School. His thesis for this work is summarized in this statement: “Nathaniel William Taylor (1786–1858), the Timothy Dwight Professor of Didactic Theology at Yale from 1822 to 1858, was arguably the most influential and the most frequently misrepresented theologian of his generation” (p. 3). Taylor and his followers claimed to be Calvinists in the tradition of Jonathan Edwards. “Unfortunately for their image in posterity,” Sweeney writes, “very few people, then or since, have believed them” (p. 4).

Taylor is often seen as a representative and perhaps even the cause of a declension in Calvinist theology in America in the nineteenth century. Taylor’s theology is often read through the lens of Charles Finney, as if Taylor is somehow responsible for this evangelist’s aberrant theology, even though there seems little reason to hold Taylor responsible for the revivalism of Finney and the Finneyites. Finney was not a student or a disciple of Taylor, even though he did popularize some of Taylor’s views. It seems unfair to hold Taylor directly accountable for Finney.

Sweeney writes to correct the misunderstanding of decades of historians’ opinions of Nathaniel Taylor. His goal is to show that Taylor’s theology was in the Edwardsian tradition, that Taylor recontextualized this Calvinist theology in the nineteenth-century American culture, that Taylor’s own works should be given more weight in the evaluation of his thought than the writings of his critics, and that Taylor’s contribution to the development of evangelicalism is under-appreciated. As Sweeney puts it, “Rather than continue the debate over whether Taylor grasped the true meaning of Edwards’s thought, I hope in what follows to elucidate the ways in which Edwardsian language shaped Taylor’s religious horizons and the ways in which, for better and for worse, Taylor carried forward the logic of the Edwardsian tradition, contributing mightily to the intellectual culture of evangelical America” (p. 12).

This is an outstanding example of evangelical historiography, an excellent contribution to the study of American religious history. Sweeney’s grasp of both the primary and secondary literature is impressive. His work nicely integrates biographical detail with theological and historical evaluation. The result is a readable, engaging story of one man’s theological heritage and influence and a glimpse into the developing revivalist tradition in America. 

Book reviews are published online and in print every quarter in Bibliotheca Sacra. Subcribe Today

Glenn R. Kreider
Dr. Kreider is professor of theological studies at Dallas Theological Seminary. He identifies his motivations as his passion for the triune God and his desire to help others respond to divine revelation in spirit and truth. Prior to coming to DTS he served as director of Christian education and pastored a church in Cedar Hill, Texas. Dr. Kreider’s research interests include Jonathan Edwards, theological method, and our eschatological hope. He is married to his best friend, Janice, and they have two grown children, a son-in-law, and one granddaughter, Marlo Grace. He and Janice enjoy live music, good stories, bold coffee, and their four rescue dogs—two pugs, a chihuahua, and an adorable black lab named Chloe.
Sep 20, 2017
Rodney H. OrrRodney H. Orr
A Wind in the House of Islam: How God Is Drawing Muslims around the World to Faith in Jesus Christ In this day, every pastor and Christian worker should have knowledge of the religion of Islam. This will help them minister to people from this background, including...
Sep 20, 2017
Glenn R. KreiderGlenn R. Kreider
American Exceptionalism and Civil Religion: Reassessing the History of an Idea Wilsey is assistant professor of history and Christian apologetics at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. In addition to teaching graduate students at the J. Dalton Havard...