Book Reviews

Retrieving Doctrine

Essays in Reformed Theology

Oliver D. Crisp Downers Grove, IL 2011-05-05

Crisp is reader in theology at the University of Bristol and visiting lecturer at Regent College in Vancouver. This work is a collection of essays on issues important to historical figures in the Reformed tradition. The author’s goal is to highlight these authors and topics from the past and show that they have significance for contemporary theology, thus retrieving them as sources for theology today.

The essays are divided into three sections. In “Creation and Providence,” Crisp interacts with John Calvin and Karl Barth. Of Calvin he concludes, “In Calvin’s way of thinking those who believe are not just spectators in this divine theatre; they are participants in this glorious work of creation, fashioned by God through the Son to be united via the work of Christ with the Father by the Holy Spirit, to the praise of his glory” (p. 25). Thus creation and providence are Trinitarian works, and those who are united to God are participants in His work in the world.

In the second section, “Sin and Salvation,” Crisp discusses Jonathan Edwards on the imputation of sin, Francis Turretin on the necessity of the incarnation, John McLeod Campbell on nonpenal substitutionary atonement, and Karl Barth’s denial of universalism. He argues that Edwards’s view of original sin has consistently been misrepresented, largely because it “is notoriously difficult to understand” (p. 47). But when correctly interpreted, Edwards “offers an intriguing response to the oft-cited criticism of imputation: that it is unfair that I am punished for another’s sin. In response to this question Edwards can claim that it is not his sin but ours” (p. 68). In short, Edwards’s position on original sin is that “Adam and his posterity are united together by God for the purposes of imputation, such that Adam’s sin becomes the sin of his posterity. They form one metaphysical unity for this purpose” (ibid.). Crisp gets Edwards right, and his essay should be read by anyone who wants to understand Edwards’s view of original sin.

The third part, “The Christian Life,” retrieves Calvin’s view of petitionary prayer, John Williamson Nevin’s view of the church, and Jonathan Edwards’s treatment of qualifications for communion. In Calvin’s view, “God ordains all that comes to pass. As such my petitioning God is part of what God has determined will obtain. . . .It is a part of the whole matrix of events that God has ordained” (pp. 152–53). In the end, “petitioning God is more about bringing my will into line with God’s will than it is seeking to change God’s mind” (p. 155). Since Edwards’s view of prayer is a bit different from Calvin’s, it would have been helpful for Crisp to have engaged him on this question. Edwards allows for a bit more mystery in prayer, agreeing that God has ordained prayer as a means of accomplishing His plan but also affirming that God does respond to the prayers of His people. It would be difficult to argue with the importance of the communion controversy in Edwards’s ministry, and Crisp rightly uses the Puritan pastor’s writings to call the contemporary evangelical church to a higher view of the Lord’s table.

This volume calls for careful and reflective reading. It is a model of how to engage with historical figures and to hear their voices in the past and bring their wisdom into the present. Understanding the past and the historical context is essential, but retrieving those voices for contemporary theology is no less important. Crisp’s work is highly recommended both for the content of these essays and as a model to be followed.

Book reviews are published online and in print every quarter in Bibliotheca Sacra. Subcribe Today

Glenn R. Kreider
Dr. Kreider is professor of theological studies at Dallas Theological Seminary. He identifies his motivations as his passion for the triune God and his desire to help others respond to divine revelation in spirit and truth. Prior to coming to DTS he served as director of Christian education and pastored a church in Cedar Hill, Texas. Dr. Kreider’s research interests include Jonathan Edwards, theological method, and our eschatological hope. He is married to his best friend, Janice, and they have two grown children, a son-in-law, and one granddaughter, Marlo Grace. He and Janice enjoy live music, good stories, bold coffee, and their four rescue dogs—two pugs, a chihuahua, and an adorable black lab named Chloe.
Sep 20, 2017
Rodney H. OrrRodney H. Orr
A Wind in the House of Islam: How God Is Drawing Muslims around the World to Faith in Jesus Christ In this day, every pastor and Christian worker should have knowledge of the religion of Islam. This will help them minister to people from this background, including...
Sep 20, 2017
Glenn R. KreiderGlenn R. Kreider
American Exceptionalism and Civil Religion: Reassessing the History of an Idea Wilsey is assistant professor of history and Christian apologetics at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. In addition to teaching graduate students at the J. Dalton Havard...