Book Reviews


Interpreted by Early Christian Commentators

J. Patout Burns Jr., editor Grand Rapids 2012-03-01

The series The Church’s Bible is a collection of fairly lengthy passages from ancient commentaries and sermon series from the first five hundred years of the church.

The volume begins with a two-page series introduction (pp. ix–x) and a ten-page section on interpreting the New Testament in the early church (pp. xiii-xxii), both written by the series editor, Robert Wilken. Burns contributes a five-page introduction that focuses on the structure of Romans, early interpretations, the text of the Pauline letters (which covers matters of manuscript evidence, the present text which follows the structure of Joseph Fitzmyer’s commentary, a rational for the passages selected, and a brief comment on access to the complete texts of some of the important ancient works on Romans; pp. xxiii–xxvii).

The body of the text is basically lengthy quotations on Romans from a number of ancient Christian writers. Each chapter begins with a brief introduction by Burns and is divided into smaller units of texts for comment. Thus each unit has a number of quotations from different writers. The Revised Standard Version translation of the passage is included. Also within the quotations the biblical text is in bold font for easy recognition. The editor allows the ancient texts to speak for themselves. There is no critique or comment on the ancient authorities.

The end of the volume includes two helpful appendixes. First is a brief discussion of ancient authors used in the volume. There are not many: Ambrosiaster, Apollinaris, Augustine, Cyril of Alexandria, Gennadius of Constantinople, John Chrysostom, Origen, Pelagius, and Theodoret. Some anonymous quotations are also included. A second appendix is a list of the references for all the quotations used in each section. In addition the book includes three indexes (names, subjects, Scripture).

The strength of this volume is that it provides lengthy comments by each author. There is enough here to help the reader get the flow of thought of the writer. Also, since there are so few authors used, one can easily follow the writings of a specific author. However, this can be misleading, since the comments do not always directly follow the original work.

InterVarsity Press is publishing a similar series called Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture (ACCS). The volume on Romans (edited by Gerald Bray, and published in 1998) is almost the same size (xvii + 404 pp.). The main difference is organization and the size of the quotations. The ACCS is organized by verse and has short quotations. Burns’s volume is organized by larger passages with much more text of the ancient authors included. Both are great for finding illustrations; however, the ACCS is easier for finding nice, short, catchy illustrations. The Church’s Bible is better for following the thought of the ancient writer on a specific passage.

This volume is helpful both for insights into Romans and for illustrations. It will be most useful for those who desire to delve into the history of interpretation. This volume can be used throughout the exegetical process but will not be a major contributor to that endeavor. The lengthy quotations allow readers to appreciate the arguments; however, readers will also need to carefully evaluate them.

Book reviews are published online and in print every quarter in Bibliotheca Sacra. Subcribe Today

Joseph D. Fantin
Dr. Fantin believes an accurate understanding of God's Word will enable the believer to grow in his or her relationship with Christ, to love God and others, to bring Christ's love to a lost world, to build up the church, and most importantly, to glorify God. He is committed to teaching exegetical method in order to help students understand, apply, and teach the Bible in order to achieve these goals. His research interests include the prison epistles, the first-century world, Greek, linguistics, and relevance theory. He and his wife, Robin, have two children: Jillian and David.
Sep 20, 2017
Rodney H. OrrRodney H. Orr
A Wind in the House of Islam: How God Is Drawing Muslims around the World to Faith in Jesus Christ In this day, every pastor and Christian worker should have knowledge of the religion of Islam. This will help them minister to people from this background, including...
Sep 20, 2017
Glenn R. KreiderGlenn R. Kreider
American Exceptionalism and Civil Religion: Reassessing the History of an Idea Wilsey is assistant professor of history and Christian apologetics at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. In addition to teaching graduate students at the J. Dalton Havard...