Book Reviews

Existential Reasons for Belief in God

A Defense of Desire and Emotions for Faith

Clifford Williams Downers Grove, IL 2011-04-05

Williams is professor of philosophy at Trinity International University. This book is needed, he argues, to provide a middle way between certain dichotomous views held by Christians. According to some, satisfaction of needs should play no role in faith; only reason can create and sustain faith. Christians also differ on the role of emotion in faith. Some reject any role for emotions, arguing that faith should be acquired only through reason. Williams believes these two dichotomies are related: “Those who believe that faith should be acquired through reason are likely to think of faith as excluding emotion. But those who believe that faith should be acquired through satisfaction of needs are likely to think of faith as consisting of emotions, for satisfaction of need involves having emotions” (p. 12).

This book addresses these two issues; whether faith responds to needs, and whether faith consists of emotions. “I answer that the ideal way to acquire faith in God is through both need and reason, and that faith should consist of both emotions and assent” (ibid.). He provides a mediating position between rationalism and emotionalism, asserting that “need without reason is blind, but reason without need is sterile” (ibid.).

Williams’s approach integrates theory and practice. Drawing on the ideas of major voices in the history of philosophy and theology, the chapters also include personal accounts of faith from interviews the author conducted. The stories include both people who experienced significant growth in faith and some who have faced real and intense struggles in their walk of faith. These stories put a “human face” on the philosophical theories presented in the book.

After an introductory section Williams devotes a chapter to defining “needs” and one to laying out an existential argument for believing in God. Then he responds to four major objections to basing faith on the satisfaction of needs. In chapter 8 he argues that faith consists of emotions and in the concluding chapter he makes three assertions: “We should let ourselves be drawn to faith in God by need; we do not always do so; and having emotions is part of what makes life spectacular” (p. 16).

Williams writes for both a professional and lay audience. He bridges the gap nicely, using terminology that is accessible for nonexperts, and his use of stories to illustrate and explain complex topics is particularly effective. Those who are interested in the role of emotions and need in acquiring and sustaining faith will be helped by this book. As a middle way between common dichotomies, his position is effective and faith-affirming. As Williams writes, “The ideal way to acquire and maintain faith is to listen to both our needs and reason. We can acquire faith on evidential arguments alone, because people have actually done so, but to do either is not as secure as acquiring it in both ways” (p. 59). 

Book reviews are published online and in print every quarter in Bibliotheca Sacra. Subcribe Today

Glenn R. Kreider
Dr. Kreider is professor of theological studies at Dallas Theological Seminary. He identifies his motivations as his passion for the triune God and his desire to help others respond to divine revelation in spirit and truth. Prior to coming to DTS he served as director of Christian education and pastored a church in Cedar Hill, Texas. Dr. Kreider’s research interests include Jonathan Edwards, theological method, and our eschatological hope. He is married to his best friend, Janice, and they have two grown children, a son-in-law, and one granddaughter, Marlo Grace. He and Janice enjoy live music, good stories, bold coffee, and their four rescue dogs—two pugs, a chihuahua, and an adorable black lab named Chloe.
Sep 20, 2017
Rodney H. OrrRodney H. Orr
A Wind in the House of Islam: How God Is Drawing Muslims around the World to Faith in Jesus Christ In this day, every pastor and Christian worker should have knowledge of the religion of Islam. This will help them minister to people from this background, including...
Sep 20, 2017
Glenn R. KreiderGlenn R. Kreider
American Exceptionalism and Civil Religion: Reassessing the History of an Idea Wilsey is assistant professor of history and Christian apologetics at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. In addition to teaching graduate students at the J. Dalton Havard...